Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Which do you prefer , a native English teacher who doesn't hold any qualifications or an experienced and qualified teacher who speaks your language?

user-image
Question added by Ahmed Gendy , English Senior Inspector , Ministry of Education (MoE)
Date Posted: 2014/04/02
anayat bukhari
by anayat bukhari , Researcher, English Content Writer, Publisher , Noor Foundation

A qualified and experienced English teacher is far better than an inexperienced and unqualified native English teacher. Unfortunately it doesn't happen so because of :

* The wrong perception about perfection in language of native speakers. (They use slangs very often which is not accepted Academically)

* Psychological reasons to attract the potential clients as students.

 

I agree with all the previous answers, far better to have a qualified teacher who speaks your language, as long as they are competent. This is what I would suggest as a general rule, however from time to you will meet non-qualified native speakers who just happen to be "naturals" at teaching but for one reason or other (later in life perhaps?) don't have recognised qualifications.

د Waleed
by د Waleed , Management - Leadership-Business Administration-HR&Training-Customer Service/Retention -Call Center , Multi Companies Categories: Auditing -Trade -Customer service -HR-IT&Internet -Training&Consultation

An experienced and qualified person should fit the position regardless if he/she is native or not.Being a native doesn't mean he/she will be able to teach properly their native language .

Khatim Abbas Seed
by Khatim Abbas Seed , BUSINESS CONSULTANT , Google

Hmmm a tricky question Mr. Gendy.

 

"A native English teacher who doesn't hold any qualifications" can still be an outstanding teacher & linguist too! And I speak out of experience with many extremely remarkable langauge & teaching talents who have no educational background in education or pedadogy, but a wealth of attained knowledge through extensive reading or some other related profession.

 

A qualified teacher who speaks a (middle) language is useful in some teaching methods pertaining to first stages of learning a foreign language (while other methods specifically ask for a native speaker). Then again, having the right qualifications does not always guarantee teaching talent, as teaching is all about conveying & sharing knowledge rather having it alone.

 

I hope this contributes sensibly to your good question.

Dr Yasmeen Majeed
by Dr Yasmeen Majeed , Trainer and HOD

I feel that an experienced teacher with innovative ideas is much better than an inexperienced native speaker.

Faridullah Shah Farid
by Faridullah Shah Farid , Stenographer/PA/Admin Officer , Tehsil Municipal Administration (TMA)

I personally100% agree with the answer of Mr. Anayat Bukhari with the addition that I have seen a number of experienced and quaified teachers with excellent and exceptional results than native speakers. 

mohammed alyamani
by mohammed alyamani , maintenance engineer , kone

A native.

Nudrat Saleem
by Nudrat Saleem , Resource Person , Tech Mahindra Foundation

English teacher who knows the native language too with the required qualifications would be my choice.

Gul Zaman
by Gul Zaman , Network Administration , vision technologies

Best answer is a mother language spook persone with experienced and qulified best of best.

More Questions Like This

Do you need help in adding the right keywords to your CV? Let our CV writing experts help you.