Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

As a creative director, would you choose to recruit a good graphic designer with average soft skills, or a mediocre one with excellent soft skills?

user-image
Question added by Salma Eid , Dietitian/Nutritionist , Muscle Power Sports, Nutrition Centre
Date Posted: 2016/08/10

When I'm in the role of creative director only really great designer can impress me. His social skills and emotional intelligence are, according to my opinion secondary but not irrelevant. In the matter of fact, his team fitting in is one of my duties. I have to  be a skillful organiser able to reconcile all character differences between my associates. So, a lack or shortage of soft skills are fixable imperfections and I have already managed not once to handle similar situations. Assessment of the other people is very tricky field and anyone with such task must be very deliberate person. Creative director must be able to motivate talented people to work with him and never to discriminate anyone on any ground. Finally, what makes sucessfull creative director is not only his strategic ability but also bringing a sense of common purpose into a team and natural authority which makes him able to reduce potential stubbornness or vanity.

Ernie Mauricio
by Ernie Mauricio , Independent Creative Consultant , Brand Hammer (Self-Employed)

I wouldn't choose either, at least not with those criteria.If by "good" and "mediocre" you're referring to talent exclusive of tenure or experience, then those criteria are not enough for me to make a decision. Skills can be trained and learned. Talent can be honed or wasted by the right and wrong attitude.What I look for in hiring people is values, attitude, and problem solving skills. In this day and age, we have all the tools we need to solve any problem--it's just not spoon-fed to us as use this tool to solve this problem. Hence, with the right attitude and the proper outlook in career (and life), any one can maximise these tools to solve any problem.In the end, I'd rather have someone who's dumb but willing to learn than someone who's good but won't listen.=)

 

Yilan Yusuf
by Yilan Yusuf , Operations Officer , Community and Social Development Project (CSDP)

It depends on what I wish to create. As a creative person, anything is resource. So, my answer is it depends.

Mohammad Salem
by Mohammad Salem , Founder , Simaa Studio

By all means and at all times I will go with the team player. In-house training would bridge the expertise gab in some time. But on the other hand, personal skills are beyond reclaim.

Lahiru Premaratne
by Lahiru Premaratne , Procurement Officer , International Golden Group

Mostly I will select who's average but versatile soft skill sets. In this way we can face most challenging projects.

Avdhesh Negi
by Avdhesh Negi , Creative Director , Panorama Productions

creative mind is already creative direction with soft and beautiful design. so you need creative designer for make it real. good skill is or average skills not required for creativity you just guide him/her.

 

Sergej  Levcenko
by Sergej Levcenko , Sale/ buy big work tehno , Dubai

Yes I'm wish choose recruit good graphik designer for Dubai or Abu- Dhabi with big clever for good rent family. Thanks! Bless!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Amer Messaikeh
by Amer Messaikeh , Founder , Free lance Fow Effect

for me i pick the one with more passion dont care wether he expert or not cuz art is never maessured with marks or time it abt the beauty in it

Khaled El-Dawy
by Khaled El-Dawy , Founder - Creative Director , PrePress Graphics

Excellent Soft Skills Can give me a good finalyzer but creative work needs a good graphic designer and soft skills can be gained

Raphael Linus Dulay
by Raphael Linus Dulay , Creative Head , Xpert Solutions

there are two types of people in terms of creativity

operators - good soft skills but might not be a good designer

designers - concept bank and can be good soft skills too  - MY PICK

Said Kamha PhD
by Said Kamha PhD , Training Manager, Local Safety Officer -Middle East , MEDA

The question is what is more important for the job, graphic design or soft skills?

If you can answer this question then the choice is clear.

 

The point is: can I have a better candidate for the job with competences matching the job requirements or should I choose between two less suitable candidates?  

More Questions Like This

Do you need help in adding the right keywords to your CV? Let our CV writing experts help you.