Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Can we install the cooling tower in an enclosed underground environment in a building?

user-image
Question added by dana tutunji , Architect , Helou Trading Co
Date Posted: 2013/06/27
Waleed Dawood
by Waleed Dawood , Regional Market Manager , Rheem

No we can not as the evaporating vapor needs to escape to the open air which requires an open area .Usually cooling towers are placed on the roof for this reason.

The answer will be no..first and foremost the efficiency of the tower will drop as answered by waleed.
Secondly, even if the top of the building is fitted with louvres, the sound level in that building will be very high due to the fan and water splashing.
Thirdly, cooling towers are renowned for bacterial and other microbial formation.
Thus, cooling towers should be well aerated.

DIPANKAR CHATTERJEE
by DIPANKAR CHATTERJEE , Overall In-charge of Western India & Accounting for Profitability , Marketing of Oil

Cooling tower being an evaporative devise that uses air to cool the re-circulating water in a cooling tower are generally located in open space. However,the same may be installed within an enclosure on ground or under ground provided the followig points are taken into consideration.

1. Adequate provision should be made for supply of fresh ambient air, through a suitable opening or air should be supplied through a fan. The air volume should be at least equel to the air volume being handled by the cooling tower fan.

2. The hot humid air from the cooling tower discharge has to be removed through an suitable opening or has to be extracted from the enclosure byusing a suitable fan. The air volume again should be little on the higher side as compared to the air volume handled by the cooling tower fan. This will minimise or prevent the re-circulation effect and also reduce te tower fouling factor.

There are instances where the cooling towers are kept out of sight by installing them within suitable enclosures that helps in noise reduction but at the same time allows adequate ambient air flowto the tower.

 

Syed Mudassir Hussain Pirzada
by Syed Mudassir Hussain Pirzada , Sr. Project Engineer , Orient Energy Systems Pvt. Ltd.

No.
Agreed with Mr.
Waleed

Basma El-Sayed
by Basma El-Sayed , متدرب , شركة الإسكندرية للبترول

We can design a natural cooling tower system placed in a center of a high cylinderical building with some door holes at its base to make air in and moving up inside the building then released from the top.
But here we must take some considerations when design the building itself.

Ismael Hamad
by Ismael Hamad , Trainer , ANTONOIL DMCC , Lukoil project, WQ2

 

Best Answer:  No, a cooling tower needs fresh air all the time to work. A cooling tower uses the evaporation of some of the water into the atmosphere to cool the rest of the water as it falls from the top down to the basin. In a closed building the air would become saturated and then the tower would no longer work effectively.

 

ishtiaq hussain zaidi
by ishtiaq hussain zaidi , Executive officer-II A/C maintenance , feroze 1888 mills ltd

we can installed but it will be costly & required more arrangement to make air in-out. through the duct we can separate the inlet & out let air of c/t. but economically, its installation is best in open air at roof.

Mustapha Hussein
by Mustapha Hussein , Consultant

Closed-Circuit-Cooling-Towerattached is a closed curcuit cooling tower . the question did you have space for that.

salman faisal
by salman faisal , Sub Engineer , Karachi Power Plant

no no cooling towers only use in open envirment

 

ismail shaikh
by ismail shaikh , hvac technician , dubai health authority

no we can not install cooling tower in enclosed under ground space .because evaporation will not be done . compressor of chiller will trip on head pressure.

Sunilumar Patel
by Sunilumar Patel , Sr. Manager , Hilti Manufacturing India Pvt. Ltd

Cooling tower evaporates water in air and hence makes the air more moist.
If cooling tower is places in coninfied space, the surounding structures near cooling tower will more prone to corrosion.
Better to place cooling tower away from main building and structure.

More Questions Like This

Do you need help in adding the right keywords to your CV? Let our CV writing experts help you.