Communiquez avec les autres et partagez vos connaissances professionnelles

Inscrivez-vous ou connectez-vous pour rejoindre votre communauté professionnelle.

Suivre

Is there any difference between instrumentation and control (I&C)engineer and automation engineer? And if so, what are the main lines for each expert?

user-image
Question ajoutée par Mohamad Yahya Mahmoud Zaid , Instrumentation and Control Consulting Engineer مهندس استشاري أجهزة دقيقة و تحكم آلي , Petroleum Pipelines Company (PPC) شركة أنابيب البترول
Date de publication: 2017/01/12
AJAY KUMAR CHANASSERY
par AJAY KUMAR CHANASSERY , Senior tech , SWIBER OFFSHORE CONSTRUCTIONS

instrumentation and control engineer with programming skill and knowledge can call automation engineer.

An Automation Engineer is responsible for the full manufacturing process to be operated automatically. 

 

The Instrumentation and Control Engineer specifically looks after the equipment that does the control (Controllers, PLC, Control Valves,...) and the instruments that provide the necessary feedback to to the control. 

Wael Zaitouni
par Wael Zaitouni , Industrial Process Control Automation/Instrumentation Engineer , University of North Texas (UNT), Electrical Engineering Department

The two roles may mean the same thing or lead to the same working environment; however, it actually depends on several factors whether to determine they are exactly the same or not. First of all, it depends on the organization’s culture, naming philosophy and the job description itself. Sometimes, for instance, the terms Instrument Engineer, Control Systems Engineer, Process Automation Engineer and Process Control Engineer may all mean the same thing or differ slightly depending upon the type, background and the industry of the organization, i.e. Vendor, EPC, End-user, consultancy, continuous process, batch, discrete manufacturing etc. For example, in some companies, an instrument engineer is the one who looks after field instruments only while in some other organizations the same position name is meant to cover control and safety systems as well. So, it is a matter of naming at the first place.

 

However, as per my experience, I have noticed that the term Control and Instrumentation Engineer is more likely to be used in EPC companies where the main function is engineering, construction, designing and document preparation of different kinds of control and instruments systems in several sites/projects rather than the system engineering, programming, and the implementation of the control hardware/software itself of a specific vendor, product, or brand. Also, I noticed that the term Automation Engineer is used in batch/discrete manufacturing industries more frequently, where PLC is the main controlling device, than being adopted in continuous process industry where DCS is the master system.  

 

In my opinion, I think the term Automation is more generic which does not necessarily infer industrial automation. In north America, for example, in addition to Industrial plant control applications, Automation is used in Software or middleware development/testing engineering as well as business automation. On the other hand, Control and Instrumentation is more precise and specific to the application of control systems and its measurement/actuation implementation (instrumentation).  

More Questions Like This

Avez-vous besoin d'aide pour créer un CV ayant les mots-clés recherchés par les employeurs?