Communiquez avec les autres et partagez vos connaissances professionnelles

Inscrivez-vous ou connectez-vous pour rejoindre votre communauté professionnelle.

Suivre

Is it grammatically correct to say has been being?

user-image
Question ajoutée par Lina Samer , Digital Media Graphic Designer , iDirection
Date de publication: 2015/12/29
fawaz ababneh
par fawaz ababneh , assistant technicianal , Irbid National Mills Co

It my be not corret grammtaily

Daisy Campos
par Daisy Campos , Executive Assistant to GM / HR & Admin In Charge , Fit-Out Company

"has been being" - no matter how awkward it may sound is actually grammatically correct.

It is a very old-fashioned way or manner of writing or talking.

It can be used to describe a state which began in the past, is continuous to the present and

may continue into the future (past-continuous action / state)

But most people will debate on that as it sounds awkward so it is still best to rephrase the thought using present perfect and still mean the same.

Ahmad Saleh
par Ahmad Saleh , Part-time English Teacher , ITA

The only correct ,though rare or even unusual , usage of such a construction which I can think of right now is the so called " perfective progressive  passive" :

- The Conservatives have not been winning seats lately. (Active Voice)

- Seats have not been being won by the Conservatives lately. (Passive Voice but Rare)

Aimen Gharbi
par Aimen Gharbi , TEACHER OF ENGLISH , Ministry ofeducation

Even though  it may be a true usage in the present progressive  I believe that such a verb "to be" is a static verb that can never be used in the contunious form in the given example.

 

Mohamed Samir LOUNES
par Mohamed Samir LOUNES , Purchasing manager - Regional processes & Operations , Henkel Algeria SPA

Hello ,

 

it appear that the sentence is not really easy to pronounce, but grammatically, it's correct.

We use the format "be being" to express that someone is acting or behaving in a way that he/she is not usually. e.g.

He is being selfish. (He is acting selfish now, he is not selfish)

Now, by sayin "have been being something" can mean that someone has been acting in a manner recently that is not / was not his character.

Pushpa Raghavan
par Pushpa Raghavan , Trainer, IELTS, PTE, Employability and communication skills training , Credo Visas (A division of Credo Careers Pvt. Ltd)

i

This question has been answered and so please refer to the previous questions and answers.  I would like to get new questions and I will be greatly interested in answering unanswered/new questions

 

Rasha Maarabouni
par Rasha Maarabouni , Executive Registrar , Lebanese International University

It's valid in the sense that it follows the rules. It is the present perfect progressive conjugation of "to be", describing an action (or in this case, a state) which began in the past, is continuous to the present, and may continue into the future.For example: "I have been being sad" makes perfect sense to me.  It differs slightly from "I have been sad", which isn't continuous, or "I am being sad", which doesn't call attention to the fact that it started in the past. 

Rania Hafez
par Rania Hafez , Office Manager , KFIC

i don't know but first time to see or hear this sentence 

More Questions Like This

Avez-vous besoin d'aide pour créer un CV ayant les mots-clés recherchés par les employeurs?