Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

What is the difference between "shell" and a "membrane" in terms of loading as applied to structures?

I think shell can take transverse loading whereas membrane can take only in-plane loading. Is that correct?

user-image
Question added by Jaffar Sadiq Ahmed Basha , Engineer , Tech Mahindra
Date Posted: 2013/10/22
Sina Tehrani
by Sina Tehrani , Civil Project Engineer , Downer

In brief I can answer you like this:

 

Membranes have in-plane stiffness : like a shear wall

Plates are elements with out-plane stiffness like a concrete slab (though we model slabs as membranes in Structural Analysis programs like Etabs to solve the problem easire)

Shells are a combination of both like a retaining wall

 

membranes only transfer in-plane forces and perpendicular moments as results of in-plane tensions and compressions. it has SDOF in rotation and2 DOF in displacement.

membrane

 

 

Plates can only endure Moments and lateral out-plane shears. it has SDOF in displacement and2 DOF in rotation.

 

plates

 

Shell = Plate + Membrane

it has6 Degree Of Freedom.

shell forces and moments

 

 

 

Vote it up if you find my answer useful

More Questions Like This

Do you need help in adding the right keywords to your CV? Let our CV writing experts help you.