Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Why the three is the preferred number? Why not use 6 or 12 phase?

user-image
Question added by mukhtar shamlan , موظف , العزب للتجارة العامة
Date Posted: 2017/02/11
Abdulrahman saeed
by Abdulrahman saeed , Technical Engineer , Al-Manhal Renewable Energy

First of all, Thank you for inviting me...

There are two reasons:

(1) using three phases results in the lowest conductor cost/watt to transmit power;

(2) using three phases displaced in space around a cylinder by 120 degrees results in a rotating magnetic field when the three phases are excited by three voltage sources displaced in time by 120 electrical degrees - this is a fundamental energy conversion principle for the operation of AC motors and generators.

in addition to

 Three phase power is the simplest form of balanced AC. Balanced meaning the power flow can be constant. A single phase system is really a two phase system, and the power through this system varies with time.

 

6 phases, and even higher (9, 12, 18, 24, etc) systems do exist, and each has small advantages. For example, in a balanced 6 phase system, the 5th and 7th harmonics do not cause torque oscillation or rotor heating in motors and generators The contributions from each 3-phase parts cancel. AC to DC rectifiers often employ AC transformers with multiple, phase shifted windings. A 3 to 6 phase transformer can be made simply by connecting the two sets of simple secondaries one in delta and the other in wye. 12 phase versions allow the input power quality reflected to the three-phase side to meet most specifications.

 

The reasons these higher order systems are not used in a commercially wide spread fashion are 1) cost and 2) the systems are indeterminate (they have more states (independent variables) than necessary for a given steady state conviction). For example, to provide constant power in six phase system, either subordinate three phase set can provide any fraction of the power necessary, unless another control is instituted such as the two three phase set must be the same. This is just more control and complication.

 

Cost is the main reason. Rotating electric machines must has at least one stator slot per phase per pole. A six phase machine has at least twice as many windings as a three phase machine. Breakers need twice as many poles, and cabling must have twice as many insulated conductors.

 

Just an aside. Non-triplen systems work as well. Some papers on 5 phase machines were published in the 80s and 90s, asserting certain benefits in motors. Some such machines have been built. They work.

 

What you ask has been considered and is employed in limited subsystems, but for main distribution, 3-phase is simple, cost effective and mathematically elegant.

Hatem   Talal  yousef Abulikbash
by Hatem Talal yousef Abulikbash , Sr.Electrical Engineer , National Engineering Bureau

Much easy using 3 phase is the optimum case in both resources (copper windings, slips,power electronic parts and control ..etc) and efficiency wise to increase than single phase by approximately 1.5 times while as we increase the phases in general the more efficient and steady power supply but in this case better to go for 3 phase to avoid complexity and since higher phases up to infinity say will not give much improvment for efficiency compared to resources used hope this answer help you . Note in some special cases we use higher phases like 48 phases or even more for specialized system like metals melting .

More Questions Like This

Do you need help in adding the right keywords to your CV? Let our CV writing experts help you.