Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Which is more accurate to measure the project work progress - Cost Or Manhours?

user-image
Question added by Labeb Ahmed , Senior Planning Engineer , Saudi Baytur Company
Date Posted: 2017/01/18
Ghaleb Sobh
by Ghaleb Sobh , Construction Manager , CCC

Most of projects willing to calculate the project progress based on the cost, as this is the way to measure the project revenue and the cash flow. However, I believe the best way to measure the project progress should be thru Man hours as this way can give us a real and physical indications for the actual work progress. For example, for road projects some main activities on site like earth works require a long time and machine works to be completed but with minor revenue, however other activities like asphalt laying can take short time but with a very high revenue, so it is a matter of compromise.

Sharafeldin Shehatah
by Sharafeldin Shehatah , Chief Executive Officer , Enforce Engineering Consultancy

 Cost or Man-hours is not an accurate way to measure the progress. The completion percentage of each task shall be measured by the quantity completed and approved by the client. then according to the weight of each task in terms of value or effort (cost or Man-hour the total progress of the project will be calculated. when you tie your Project to the Bill of quantity it will be easy and more accurate to use the cost as a weight for the tasks. 

Muhammad Irfan Chughtai
by Muhammad Irfan Chughtai , IT Project Manager , Buzzeff Middle East

You select metric based on your required measurement. 

1. In order to measure Schedule Progress you would use Man-hours.

2. In order to measure Cost efficiency on the project you would use Planned vs Actual Cost.  

Kiran Jacob
by Kiran Jacob , Electronics and Instrumentation Engineer , Automation and telecomunication services

man hour units. and it may depend  if we are increasing a amn hour unit with a unskillled labour then we wont get any good results.

Cliff James
by Cliff James , Electrical Foreman , Laird Electric

Cost based is more accurate

Shaalan Omar
by Shaalan Omar , Planning Engineer , AKT Oil Services Company

Procurments activities must measured by using Cost while all other activities depend in measurments on Manhoures. 

Alaaeddin Abd El-Razek
by Alaaeddin Abd El-Razek , Lecturer , Egyptian Army

The Cost Ratio method is usually implemented on a project , this technique is measured based on the budgeted allocation of currency vs. the labour hours of production.

Muhammad Kassab  CPA CMA CertIFR
by Muhammad Kassab CPA CMA CertIFR , Accounting Manager , Marine Buildings Landmarks

in the Percentage of completion method for the revenue recognition for long period projects ( under US GAPP ) Percentage of completion is the accumulated cost incurred (up to the time of calculation) divided by the total estimated cost for the whole project ( actual incurred + estimated remaining )

 

Percentage of completion = Cost Incurred / Total cost estimated 

Osama ahmad
by Osama ahmad , Commissioning Engineer , Al Toukhi Company for Industry and Trading

Project work progress can only be calculated by the manhour units.

Muhammad Umar Farooq
by Muhammad Umar Farooq , IT Program Leader , Petro Rabigh

Earned Value Management (EVM) is a technique that can help you measure the project progress in terms of cost.

 

To get more information on Project Management, follow the following page:

https://www.facebook.com/ProjectLife-1112296792185437

Nandish Baxi
by Nandish Baxi , Business Planning Manager , Spiritual Foresees

Cost base is recommended most accurate. 

More Questions Like This

Do you need help in adding the right keywords to your CV? Let our CV writing experts help you.