Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Is there any strength difference in concrete cured by curing compound and water cured?

user-image
Question added by oman faruq , Jr. Engineer, Feasibility Study and Detail Design (FSDD) Under SSWRDSP & PSSWRSP of LGED. , Bets Consultants Ltd.
Date Posted: 2013/09/14
Arif Mukhtar Rana
by Arif Mukhtar Rana , A.R.E. (Highways) , Saudi Consult Center (KSA)

the effect is but not so appreciable ultimately durability of concrete is reduced

NO there is not and my experience in using the curing compound in hot weather concreting is even seeing some cracks on top surface and ive never seen any more strength that way but curing the concrete with pressurize water vapor can increase the strength and the shorten the strength gaining of concrete very very much as per my experiences.specially when we need a high speed strength gaining in pre tentioned concrete slabs

Osman Guni
by Osman Guni , STRUCTURAL ENGINEER , BUREAU VERITAS (BAN) PVT LTD

I don't think you can simply say one results in a higher strength than the other because they are two different methods of curing concrete. Curing compound theoretically traps water and prevents loss of water during the concrete for the curing process. Using water to cure concrete essentially replaces water loss, to insure that water is available for the curing process. If both processes are done properly, it should not have an impact on the strength. What I have seen is curing compound manufacturers using wording like, increases strenght over improperly or uncured concrete. No kidding? One could just as easily say if you cure concrete properly, it is stronger than if you don't. One advantage curing compounds do provide is increased tensile strength to help reduce heat cracking and surface cracking. I have always been told strenght charecterstics depend on two things, the mixture design and the placement. If you design it properly and you place it properly, you will typically get the desired end strength. Curing is part of the equation. If you do it properly with curing compound or water, you'll likely get typical results.

Wolf Klaas Kinsbergen
by Wolf Klaas Kinsbergen , Managing Director, Designer , ingenieursbureau KB International NV

yes, Curing compund is only put on the service of the concrete to create a tension on the surface so water evaporates less.

If you change the water in the mixure it will effect the complete mixture

Abrar Akbar
by Abrar Akbar , Design Engineer & ISO Co-Ordinator , Izhar Steel Pvt Limited

Well i think so there will be no differnce as the mixture is same and ur only purpose is to cure that not to change its mix properties so that why thre will be no drastic effect 

More Questions Like This

Do you need help in adding the right keywords to your CV? Let our CV writing experts help you.