Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Assume that a firm has accurately calculated the net cash flows relating to an investment proposal.

If the net present value of this proposal is greater than zero and the firm is not under the constraint of capital rationing, then the firm should:

 

calculate the IRR of this investment to be certain that the IRR is greater than the cost of capital.

 

compare the profitability index of the investment to those of other possible investments.

 

calculate the payback period to make certain that the initial cash outlay can be recovered within an appropriate period of time.

 

accept the proposal, since the acceptance of value-creating investments should increase shareholder wealth.

user-image
Question added by Emad Mohammed said abdalla , ERP & IT Software, operation general manager . , AL DOHA Company
Date Posted: 2015/04/02

My answer is option (D) accept the proposal

Paolo Borchetta
by Paolo Borchetta , Managing Director , NIMM International Mauritanie Mining

I would add another comment to clarify the concept.

The NPV should have already be calculated using the WACC as discount rate, this includes by definition all the components that reward the shareholders over and above a risk free investment rate (RFR) + Equity Beta (levered) + Market Risk Premium (MPR) + if applicable Size Premium (SP) = Cost Of Equity (COE).

In essence the WACC already implies a value creation for the shareholders.

If the discount rate was different from the WACC (in case of investment proposals from one party to another), then the IRR should be calculated just as additional verification and the IRR should be equal or higher than the WACC in order to create shareholders wealth.

The calculation of the WACC is subject to much debate and scholarship so it is not, for some of its components, a straight forward process and might vary from party to party. So a prior agreement on the WACC figure saves a lot of time later.

Emad Mohammed said abdalla
by Emad Mohammed said abdalla , ERP & IT Software, operation general manager . , AL DOHA Company

>>>>> accept the proposal, since the acceptance of value-creating investments should increase shareholder wealth.

Wasi Rahman Sheikh
by Wasi Rahman Sheikh , WAREHOUSE SUPERVISOR , AL MUTLAQ FURNITURE MFG

Option forth is answer ????????????????//

khaled elkholy
by khaled elkholy , HR MANAGER , misk for import & export

accept the proposal, since the acceptance of value-creating investments should increase shareholder wealth..!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!??!!

Nasir Hussain
by Nasir Hussain , Sales And Marketing Manager , Pakistan Pharmaceutical Products Pvt. Ltd.

.... . . .

..... . . .

....... . . .

accept the proposal, since the acceptance of value-creating investments should increase shareholder wealth......... . . .

 

Anas  Dawah
by Anas Dawah , Senior Internal Auditor , Talal Abu-Ghazaleh Global (TAGI)

d_______________________________________________________________________

accept the proposal, since the acceptance of value-creating investments should increase shareholder wealth.

Mohammed Shahid Ullah
by Mohammed Shahid Ullah , Executive Director (Finance) , Coal Power Generation Company Bangladesh Limited

calculate the IRR of this investment to be certain that the IRR is greater than the cost of capital. The project which is less cost of capital then IRR will be considered for capital rationing purpose.

 

Thanks to experts 

Well answers 

Muhammad Ramzan Tufail  ACCA
by Muhammad Ramzan Tufail ACCA , Assistant Finance Manager , Eltizam Asset Management Group

Correct Ans is :

 

Accept the proposal, since the acceptance of value-creating investments should increase shareholder wealth.>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Nalin Shamika Prasad Ramanayake Ramanayake
by Nalin Shamika Prasad Ramanayake Ramanayake , Assistant Relationship Manager , EmiratesNBD

In terms of considering a standalone investment proposal pertaining to the firm and accuracy of NPV calculation based on firm-wide WACC, the answer would ideally be the 4th.

Do you need help in adding the right keywords to your CV? Let our CV writing experts help you.