Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

How reliable is the structural analysis results from solid works FEA tool. How will you compare it with other dedicated softwares like ANSYS?

Explain in terms of meshing and stress distribution results

user-image
Question added by HARIKRISHNAN R , Principal Mechanical Engineer , Methode Electronics, Inc.
Date Posted: 2014/10/11
Shahid Rabbani
by Shahid Rabbani , Assistant Manager Production , Dawlance Group of Companies

I have experience of using structural mechanics module both in Solidworks and Ansys Workbench. As far as solidworks is concerned, it is really god for CAD modelling. In recent years, they have introduced some simulation packages as well, but I didn't find them much user friendly and reliable while comparing results from Ansys Workbench. The best one can do is, make CAD model in solidworks, export to Ansys Workbench in 'stl' format, mesh it there and perform structural analysis there. I hope this answers your question.

Eby Mathai
by Eby Mathai , Engineering Manager , KeM Engineering Services LLC

FEA in Solidworks is with the collaboration of Ansys. Its very limited options. Its helpful for doing basic Analysis.

Limitation:

Supports only Static cases.

Dont support Analysis on Assembly

Meshing is automatic and Tet.

 

Advantages with Ansys

Dedicated software for Structural, Thermal, Electromagnetic etc.

Very powerful Meshing options: hex mash.

Loads can be applied on particular nodes too.

 

In general we cant compare FEM in Solidworks with that  of Ansys. Its just of a drop from an Ocean.

Do you need help in adding the right keywords to your CV? Let our CV writing experts help you.