Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

Academics bring up the ideas and the world of business turn it into money. Do you agree ??

user-image
Question added by Nancy Refai , Health, safety and environmental management Trainer and consultant , Freelancer
Date Posted: 2014/07/26
Khatim Abbas Seed
by Khatim Abbas Seed , BUSINESS CONSULTANT , Google

Mostly but not entirely. 

 

Business, in my opinion, is not an abstract discipline like math or physics are. The latter disciplines were substantiated, made understandable and put to useful use by the mass (when education was reserved for the elite, before the industrial revolution) through observation, experimentation and analysis. They are undeniably to be attributed to academic scholarship than to business. 

 

But businesses, entrepreneurship and businessmen as entities, on the other hand, were always there since ancient times. They are the that who shape(d) both, the contours and content of business books back then and nowadays, frequently "inviting other disciplines in" to provide invention, analysis or improvement. Like psychology (and IT = internet) in marketing and physics, biology, chemistry, math and technology in production, logistics and accounting, for example.

 

A successful business strategy that goes against existing acadmic theory, will sooner or later find its way to business books, but a genius but detached academic theory that proves useless in real business life will scrap itself from mainstream business books, evidently.

 

Not the best example, but certainly one. SPAM emails used to be accepted (or untackled) as a form of "mass marketing" until filtering and opt-in technology presented themsleves (through non-business science) allowing businesses to devise & dictate the best new policy, to be taught in new business books. Business were the first ones to decide that spam was evidently bad for them, then came the analysis and technology to provide a possible solution.

I agree to disagree! In the first instance "necessity is the mother of invention", it didn't  necessarily take an "academic" to invent the wheel, it probably took someone who was really tired and fed up with carrying heavy weights to think "there must be a better more simple way of doing this"! Having said that, most academics enjoy the challenge of solving problems and couple that with some timely entrepeurnership and financial "clout" and you will possibly have a money making situation!!

Sidrah Nadeem
by Sidrah Nadeem , Global Marketing Manager , Hill+Knowlton Strategies

Pretty much,

Saiful Islam Hiron
by Saiful Islam Hiron , Site HR Manager , Handicap International

Yes I do agree with you due to academic institutions produce potential to lead the business.

Umesh Nair
by Umesh Nair , Sales Manager , Muna Noor Manufacturing & Trading LLC

You need not be an acedemic to come up with an idea. Anyone can come up with idea. The role of scholars/academics is to try to find solutions to complex problems which are bugging our world.

 

Converting an idea into a successful business is easier said than done and morphing the business into a

serious money making one even more difficult.

IRPHAN GHANI
by IRPHAN GHANI , Senior Management , A

Yes I agree and wish to add that the world of business creates experience to learn from for more valuable learning.

Hayel Oraikat
by Hayel Oraikat , Country General Manager , DORMAKABA

Agree by far, because the academic study is the foundation.

syed syed
by syed syed , Director-MBA , Syed Ammal Engineering College

True and false! It depends on academics as individuals. Majority may be like that, however there are a number of true blue academics who abhor fame and money and they are intrinsically rich and contended. Money and power can not buy knowledge. And wisdom is too high to be scaled.

Muhammad Farooq
by Muhammad Farooq , Science Teacher , HIGH School Virk

yes100% agree

More Questions Like This

Do you need help in adding the right keywords to your CV? Let our CV writing experts help you.