ابدأ بالتواصل مع الأشخاص وتبادل معارفك المهنية

أنشئ حسابًا أو سجّل الدخول للانضمام إلى مجتمعك المهني.

متابعة

In creating an artwork, which is much easier to use Indesign, Illustrator or Photoshop? Explain your answer.

user-image
تم إضافة السؤال من قبل Rafael Paolo Malonzo , Graphic Designer , Freelancer
تاريخ النشر: 2014/07/09
Muhammad Fahd Altaf Altaf
من قبل Muhammad Fahd Altaf Altaf , Team Lead Web Services , Launchpad Interactive

If you need to publish book or printing material like manuals, multipages brochures etc then best option is Indesign.

If you need photo editing use photoshop

and if you need graphics in vector format then use illustrator.

 

To create an amazing art work the combination of illustrator and photoshop works perfect in99.9%.

Anas Alhammoud
من قبل Anas Alhammoud , CEO , Aldura Real Estate & Trading Group

In my opinion ... Photoshop use the best that you can start it in the artwork and thus easier to use

Badruddin Badruddin
من قبل Badruddin Badruddin , Masters Student (completed with Distinction) , Bournemouth University

In my experience, the software is just a tool. It's like asking what makes a better drawing, pencil or charcoal?

In my opinion, yes you definitely need to consider what medium your artwork needs to be in, print or digital for instance, but at the end of the day everything boils down to the artist's ability to be creative regardless of what tools are involved.

And usually a mixture of tools are used to create any final works, so my advice is always to learn the principles of art/colour/design/animation/etc. because relying on tools is not a good idea. They change, and being flexible is always better.  

imran khan
من قبل imran khan , Sr. Graphic Design , Click Media Advertising

If I want to make a Magzine or Newspaper page Its better to use Indesign, but some where Designers Use Corel Draw too,

In Digital Printng We Can Use Illustrator & Corel Draw, Illustrator also uses For Web Development & Other Illustrations Like LOGOs Etc.....

& Finaly Photoshop's top work is to Edit photos To Illustrate Photos, In my Expirience Photoshop is90% must for any type Of designing

If this artwork is a magazine so you should use InDesign.

If this artwork is a logo so you should use Illustrator.

If this artwork is a digital painting so you should use Photoshop.

Randy Jay Cua
من قبل Randy Jay Cua , Part-time IT/CS Instructor , Andres Soriano Colleges of Bislig

I think the best software that is to be used is Photoshop. It provides a simple and common commands for different projects.

Darpan Rane
من قبل Darpan Rane , Senior Art Director - 360 , Infinity - The Agency

Tricky one! It can never be a one sided affair. Depends on the nature of assignment.

 

  • Photoshop put you in ease when photo-editing, showcasing realistic renders for Branding collaterals, fine art etc.
  • Illustrator put you in ease creating logos, branding collaterals, cartoon-semi to realistic illustrations, web interface design & other vector symbols.
  • Indesign is a salvation when it comes to designing marketing collaterals like brochures, books, simple websites, outdoor advertising materials as it allows you to work in3 modes - Text, Low Pixel & High Performance.

 

Together, they form the "Trinity" of Design Lovers! Cheers!

yasmin ismail
من قبل yasmin ismail , foreign purchasing specialist in Global , Sourysco International Company

If  you need photo editor or roster designs and digital paintaing photoshop is perfect to use

but if you need a vector designs for a huge flair illestrator will be the best

illestrtor also is better in designing logos

indesign is used for books , magazin, brochure,

Jayson Aglubat
من قبل Jayson Aglubat , Graphic Designer/Information Technology , Local Government

Well it depend on the field of artwork and it is much easier if the artwork both created by that three software, 

 

Hafiz Salman Ahmed
من قبل Hafiz Salman Ahmed , assistant manager production , Bolan Castings Limited

for photoediting u should use photoshop

Abdel-rahman Hassan Kamel Abdel Samad
من قبل Abdel-rahman Hassan Kamel Abdel Samad , Senior Project Architect , AEB

i don't know which one is the easiest, as i didn't use another programs ,just photoshop i used to use it to finish final photos for my projects

المزيد من الأسئلة المماثلة

هل تحتاج لمساعدة في كتابة سيرة ذاتية تحتوي على الكلمات الدلالية التي يبحث عنها أصحاب العمل؟